When Congress enacted the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act (PSLRA) of 1995,1 its stated objective was to shift control of securities class actions away from trial lawyers and toward institutional investors with significant financial stakes. To achieve this, the PSLRA requires courts to adopt a rebuttable presumption that the investor with the “largest financial interest” in the relief sought is the “most adequate plaintiff.”2 Despite that structural preference for institutional plaintiffs, individual investors continue to lead more than half of the securities class actions that result in settlements.
How Often Individual Investors Lead Cases to Settlement
While major institutions frequently lead the market’s largest cases, industry data shows that individual investors remain highly active across the broader docket. In 2025 alone, individual investors led 53 securities class actions that resulted in a settlement, accounting for 72% of all settled cases that year. That pattern is not a recent development; between 2016 and 2025, individuals led 451 settlements, representing 56% of all successful recoveries during that decade.
Settlement Size and the Institutional Advantage
Because the PSLRA ties the lead plaintiff presumption to financial interest, major institutional investors, such as public pension funds, tend to secure appointment in the largest cases. Individual investors, by contrast, predominate in smaller settlements. The divergence is measurable. For settlements finalized in 2025, the rate of individual-led settlements below $50 million was 73%, compared to 64% for settlements above $50 million. The historical picture from 2016 to 2025 shows a larger gap: individual investors led 63% of settlements under $50 million, versus 21% of those exceeding $50 million. For settlements of $25 million or less, individual investors led 69% of settlements.
Outliers do exist. In re Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. Securities Litigation, which settled for $433.5 million, was led by an individual lead plaintiff.3 Likewise, In re DiDi Global Inc. Securities Litigation settled for $740 million without a large institutional lead plaintiff.4
Economic research supports this pattern. Analysis by NERA Economic Consulting identifies the presence of an institution or public pension fund as lead plaintiff as one of the primary factors associated with higher settlement amounts.5
Why Individual Investors Continue to Lead Cases
Major institutional investors frequently forgo seeking lead plaintiff appointment unless their losses are exceptionally large, which means smaller and mid-sized cases present individual investors with meaningful losses with a genuine opportunity to step in. Individual investors may also form small, cohesive groups to aggregate their losses, allowing them to satisfy the PSLRA’s financial interest requirement and secure appointment in cases where no single investor’s losses would be sufficient on their own.
The PSLRA was designed to favor institutional leadership, and the data confirms that institutions drive the largest recoveries. At the same time, individual investors fill a real and recurring role across the broader securities litigation landscape, particularly in cases where institutions pass and no single investor commands dominant financial interest.
Investors who believe they purchased securities during the class period of a pending case and would like to understand their options, including whether the size of their losses may support a lead plaintiff motion, are welcome to contact Kirby McInerney at investigations@kmllp.com. KM evaluates potential claims at no cost, and the conversation does not create an attorney-client relationship.
- 15 U.S.C. § 78u-4. ↩︎
- 15 U.S.C. § 78u-4(a)(3)(B)(iii). ↩︎
- In re Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. Securities Litigation, No. 1:20-cv-09568-GBD-JW (S.D.N.Y.). ↩︎
- In re DiDi Global Inc. Securities Litigation, No. 1:21-cv-05807-LAK-VF (S.D.N.Y.). ↩︎
- Edward Flores, Svetlana Starykh, and Ivelina Velikova, Recent Trends in Securities Class Action Litigation: 2025 Full-Year Review, NERA (Jan. 21, 2026), https://www.nera.com/content/dam/nera/publications/2026/PUB_2025_Recent_SCA_Trends_Full-Year_0121.pdf. ↩︎